Ever met someone who constantly puts themselves down yet never seems to tire of talking about themselves? The self-deprecating narcissist is a peculiar creature. At first, their self-effacing comments seem endearingly humble, even charmingly awkward. But pay closer attention, and you’ll notice that all those putdowns and qualifications only serve to keep the focus squarely on them.
For the self-deprecating narcissist, humility is just another tool to cultivate an image of attractive vulnerability while still monopolizing the conversation. Their putdowns are performative, engineered to garner praise and compliments to feed their bottomless ego. So the next time someone showers you with self-deprecating humor, don’t be so quick to reassure them. Their ego may not need any more stroking. They know exactly what they’re doing—making sure all eyes remain on them.
Table of Contents
The Self-Deprecating Narcissist: A Contradiction in Terms?
They seem like contradictions. How can someone be both narcissistic, meaning overly self-absorbed, but also frequently put themselves down? The truth is, these traits can coexist in the same person.
Self-deprecating narcissists crave attention and praise from others to boost their self-esteem. However, they also have an underlying sense of inadequacy and insecurity. By putting themselves down in an exaggerated, humorous way, they are essentially fishing for compliments. They want you to protest and lavish them with reassurance and adoration.
For example, they might post something on social media like, “Just woke up and look like a hot mess as usual! #thestruggleisreal”. They are pointing out a perceived flaw to elicit comments from friends and followers affirming how great they look.
The problem is that, over time, the self-deprecation and need for constant validation become a turn-off. Friends and family get tired of having to provide over-the-top praise and reassurance. The self-deprecating narcissist never develops healthy self-esteem from within. Their fragile ego remains dependent on the reactions and opinions of others.
The contradictions in the self-deprecating narcissist stem from deep-seated insecurities that they have never addressed. With self-awareness and a desire for real personal growth, one can overcome unhealthy behaviors. But they must first accept themselves as they are, imperfections and all. Only then will the need for self-deprecation and external validation fade away.
Read more
The Connection Between Self-Deprecation and Narcissism
They may seem like contradictions, but these traits often go hand in hand. People who constantly put themselves down in an exaggerated way are usually doing it as a cover for their insecurity and need for admiration.
Self-deprecation is a common defense mechanism. By loudly pointing out their own perceived flaws and shortcomings, they are attempting to lower the expectations of others and gain reassurance. They want you to shower them with compliments and praise to make up for their self-criticism.
The Role of Insecurity and Low Self-Esteem
Underneath the bravado and apparent self-confidence, they struggle with feelings of inadequacy, anxiety, and low self-worth. Their fragile ego needs constant bolstering, so they turn to self-deprecation as a way to fish for compliments and validation. They may put on an act of humility and self-effacement, all the while secretly believing they are superior to others.
Some common traits and behaviors of self-deprecating narcissists include:
- excessive bragging about their achievements and talents followed by self-criticism
- seeking out constant praise and admiration while claiming not to deserve it
- Envying the success and good fortune of others while believing they deserve better
- difficulty handling criticism and perceiving it as a personal attack
- Fluctuating between feelings of grandiosity and worthlessness
They are stuck in a cycle of self-sabotage and crave external validation to make up for their inner sense of inadequacy. Their self-esteem is entirely dependent on the reactions and opinions of others, rather than their self-acceptance. The contradiction of self-deprecation and narcissism is a mask for deep insecurity and vulnerability.
Identifying a Self-Deprecating Narcissist
These individuals seem like contradictions, but this personality type does exist. How can you spot one? Here are some clues to look for:
The constant need for admiration
While self-deprecating narcissists put themselves down, they still crave admiration and praise from others. They may make frequent self-demeaning comments, fishing for compliments and ego-stroking from those around them. For example, saying something like, “I’m so dumb; you’re so much smarter than me!” This is a ploy for you to disagree and shower them with accolades.
Sense of entitlement
Though self-deprecating on the surface, these individuals still feel entitled to privileges and special treatment. They believe the rules don’t apply to them and that they deserve success and rewards without effort or accountability. For instance, taking extra long lunches or delegating work to others that they are responsible for
Lack of empathy
These individuals typically show little genuine interest in others or the ability to understand their feelings. They are too focused on themselves to show real compassion for the people around them. They may go through the motions of asking how you’re doing but then quickly shift the conversation back to themselves.
Read more
Exaggerated achievements
While they put themselves down in some ways, they also tend to exaggerate their achievements. They constantly draw attention to their perceived successes in an attempt to gain admiration. For example, taking credit for team efforts or inflating their actual contributions
If someone in your life exhibits these traits, be cautious. While their self-deprecating comments may seem harmless or even endearing, these individuals can be manipulative and lack real concern for others. Look for other signs of narcissism beyond just what they say about themselves to determine if this personality type applies.
The Root Causes of Self-Deprecating Narcissism
The root causes of self-deprecating narcissism stem from a mix of nature and nurture. Genetics may predispose someone to narcissistic traits, but environment and upbringing also play a significant role in the development of this contradictory personality type.
Some possibilities for the origins of self-deprecating narcissism include:
Low self-esteem
Underneath the bravado, narcissists often have a fragile sense of self-worth. Constantly seeking validation and praise from others betrays deep feelings of inadequacy. Self-deprecating comments may be a misguided attempt to appear more humble and likable to compensate for insecurity.
Read more
Emotional neglect
Children who do not receive enough affection, praise, and nurturing from parents or caregivers may become narcissistic as a way to cope with emotional deprivation. The self-deprecating narcissist adopts an overblown ego to make up for the lack of unconditional love in their formative years.
Perfectionism
Excessively high standards for achievement and an unrelenting inner critic can fuel the cycle of grandiosity and self-criticism. Narcissists set unrealistic expectations for themselves to attain worth and value. When they inevitably fall short, they berate themselves to relieve feelings of imperfection and defectiveness.
Manipulation
Some self-deprecating narcissists employ false humility and self-effacement as a way to manipulate others. Putting themselves down in a woe-is-me fashion elicits sympathy, praise, and reassurance from those around them. This feeds their constant need for attention and validation.
Read more
The interplay between these factors likely produces the peculiar combination of self-absorption and self-contempt that defines self-deprecating narcissism. Healing this psychological contradiction will require conscious effort and insight to overcome destructive thought patterns, build self-compassion, set healthy boundaries, and cultivate authentic, mutually caring relationships.
How Self-Deprecating Narcissists Seek Attention and Validation
They seek attention and validation in contradictory ways. On the one hand, their self-deprecating comments seem humble and designed to make others comfortable. But in reality, these remarks are fishing for compliments and reassurance. They want you to build them back up after they’ve torn themselves down.
Compliments Are Their oxygen.
They rely on the kind words and praise of others as much as we rely on oxygen. Compliments are essential for their self-esteem and sense of worth. So when they criticize themselves, even in a lighthearted way, they’re subtly manipulating you into paying them a compliment. If you don’t take the bait, they may up the ante with increasingly negative comments until you do.
They may say something like:
- “I’m so stupid; I can never figure these things out.”
- “You’re so much better at this than I am.”
- “Why do you even put up with me?”
What they’re thinking is:
- “Tell me I’m not stupid.”
- “Reassure me that I’m good at other things.”
- “Give me reasons why you value me.”
The self-deprecating narcissist’s ego is fragile, so they rely on external sources to prop it up. The problem is that the compliments they receive never satisfy them for long. Like an addict, they constantly need another hit of praise and validation.
Don’t Take the bait.
The healthiest approach for these individuals is not to take the bait. Don’t feel obligated to offer compliments and praise every time they put themselves down. Politely acknowledging their comment without building them back up is the best strategy. Say something neutral, like:
- “I see.”
- “Interesting that you feel that way.”
- “Sorry, you feel that way about yourself.”
Over time, they may learn that self-deprecation isn’t an effective way to get their needs met and may develop healthier self-esteem regulation as a result. You can offer compliments and praise when they’re truly deserved and meaningful, but avoid being manipulated into constant ego-stroking. Your emotional support will never fill the bottomless pit of validation a self-deprecating narcissist craves. Ultimately, you need to accept them as they are or establish better boundaries. The choice is yours.
Effects of Self-Deprecating Narcissism on Personal Growth
Their tendency to put themselves down can significantly hinder their personal growth and development. Their self-criticism and inability to acknowledge their strengths stand in the way of empowering themselves.
Impact on Self-Confidence
Constantly belittling yourself erodes your self-confidence over time. Even if said in jest, your self-deprecating words are internalized and become your self-perception. You start to doubt yourself and your abilities, hesitating to take on new challenges or pursue opportunities for fear of failure or not being “good enough”. Building confidence requires recognizing your strengths, skills, and accomplishments—something the self-deprecating narcissist struggles with.
Difficulty Setting Boundaries
Those who put themselves down have trouble establishing healthy boundaries. They may feel they don’t deserve to have their needs met or are not worthy of respect from others. As a result, they tolerate poor treatment and let others take advantage of them. Setting boundaries is an act of self-care and empowerment, requiring you to value yourself and your well-being. For these individuals, this can feel impossible.
Fear of Success
They are often afraid of success due to a fear of change and the belief that they are undeserving. Achieving goals or gaining status means having to acknowledge their abilities and strengths, which triggers feelings of discomfort. It is easier to remain in a familiar state of self-doubt than to accept and embrace success. However, avoiding success and growth leads to feelings of stagnation, a lack of purpose, and unfulfilled potential.
Overcoming these effects and achieving personal empowerment requires a conscious effort to challenge negative self-beliefs, practice self-compassion, set boundaries, and take calculated risks. It won’t happen overnight, but with time and work, they can develop a healthier and more balanced self-perception.
The Cycle of Grandiosity and Self-Loathing
The self-deprecating narcissist continually fluctuates between feelings of grandiosity and self-loathing. One moment, they see themselves as the best at everything, smarter and more talented than others. Next, they harshly criticize themselves for the smallest perceived flaws and imperfections. This cycle perpetuates itself, keeping them trapped.
Grandiosity
When these people are riding high on grandiose feelings, they believe they are superior to others in looks, intelligence, and accomplishments. They crave admiration and praise from those around them to validate these unrealistic beliefs about themselves. However, these extreme highs are often followed by crashes into self-doubt and loathing.
Self-Loathing
After the thrill of grandiosity wears off, they begin to see all their perceived flaws, faults, and imperfections exaggeratedly. They become plagued by feelings of inadequacy, insecurity, and a sense of worthlessness. In this state, they require constant reassurance from others while also rejecting any compliments that are offered. The smallest criticism can send them spiraling even deeper into self-loathing.
This up-and-down cycle continues on and on, with the self-deprecating narcissist bouncing between overly confident highs and desperately insecure lows. In the highs, they believe they are superior; in the lows, they feel worthless. The extremes in this cycle tend to become more severe over time without conscious effort or awareness.
The key to breaking this unhealthy cycle is developing self-awareness and a balanced, realistic view of yourself, both good and bad. Appreciating your genuine strengths and talents, accepting your imperfections with compassion, and avoiding extremes of idealization and condemnation With practice and patience, you can overcome self-deprecating narcissism and establish healthy self-esteem.
Empowering Growth and Transformation
To overcome these tendencies, you must commit to real personal growth and transformation. This is a journey, not a destination, but the rewards of increased self-awareness, contentment, and healthy relationships make the effort worthwhile.
Develop Emotional intelligence.
Work to understand your own emotions and reactions better, as well as show empathy towards others. Pay close attention to how your words and actions impact people. Try putting yourself in the shoes of someone else and seeing the situation from their perspective. Ask open-ended questions to make sure you understand their feelings and point of view.
Practice Self-Compassion
Learn to be kind to yourself. Avoid harsh self-judgment and criticism. Speak to yourself with the same compassion you would show a friend. Recognize your weaknesses and flaws, but also appreciate your good qualities and strengths. Permit yourself to be imperfect.
Read more
Seek Feedback and Accept criticism.
Ask trusted friends or a therapist for honest but constructive feedback about your behaviors and tendencies. Be open to hearing criticism without defensiveness. Look for the kernel of truth in what they say and use it as an opportunity for growth. Thank them for caring enough to provide input.
Set Small Goals and Celebrate wins.
Don’t feel overwhelmed by the amount of change needed. Set small, concrete goals and build upon them. Focus on progress, not perfection. Congratulate yourself on achievements and milestones along the way. Reward yourself to stay motivated for continued improvement.
Continuously Self-Reflect
Make time for regular self-reflection through journaling, meditation, or quiet contemplation. Explore how your past experiences and beliefs have shaped your self-image and behaviors. Gain insight into unhealthy patterns and look for ways to revise them. Be authentic and vulnerable in your reflections. Growth happens outside your comfort zone.
The journey to overcoming self-deprecating narcissism and cultivating a healthy self-image is challenging but rewarding. Stay committed to the process of self-discovery and surround yourself with a strong support system. You have the power to transform yourself through empathy, compassion, and conscious effort. Believe in your ability to change and become your best self.
Conclusion
You know the type—constantly putting themselves down in public yet somehow making it all about them. The self-deprecating narcissist seems like an oxymoron, but it could be more common than you think. While their outward self-criticism seems to contradict a self-centered personality, it’s often just a clever disguise to mask their fragile ego and insatiable need for attention. Their put-downs are a call for compliments, and their humility is a way to highlight their accomplishments.
So the next time someone showers you with a litany of their perceived faults and flaws, don’t be so quick to reassure them. Their self-deprecation could be just another manifestation of their narcissism peeking through. It looks like you can’t judge this book by its cover after all. The self-deprecating narcissist: a contradiction in terms or a wolf in sheep’s clothing? You be the judge.
References
- “It’s not you, it’s me”: transformational leadership and self-deprecating humor Colette Hoption, Julian Barling, Nick Turner , Leadership & Organization Development Journal, ISSN: 0143-7739
- PDF] Self-Defeating vs Self–Deprecating Humour: A Case of Being Laughed At vs. Laughed With? by R Brown – Melbourne: Swinburne University of Melbourne
Let’s boost your self-growth with Believe in Mind.
Interested in self-reflection tips, learning hacks, and knowing ways to calm down your mind? We offer you the best content which you have been looking for.